Limited or Umbrella? Choosing the Right Option for You

One of the first decisions contractors face is whether to work through their own limited company or join an umbrella company. While both options are fully compliant with UK tax law, they each carry different advantages, responsibilities, and levels of control.

Understanding the differences is key, as the right choice depends on factors such as contract length, earning potential, IR35 status, and how involved you want to be with administration. Below, we’ve set out the pros, cons, and suitability of each route.

Limited Company: Maximum Control and Tax Efficiency

Operating through a limited company can be highly rewarding, offering greater control over your finances and often resulting in higher take-home pay when compared with an umbrella company.

Best suited for contractors who:

  • Intend to contract on a long-term basis or hold multiple contracts

  • Want to maximise their earnings through tax-efficient planning

  • Prefer to retain full control over their business and finances

  • Earn above £500 per week or around £25,000 per year

Key benefits:

  • Higher earning potential – You can draw income through a combination of salary and dividends, often resulting in a greater take-home pay.

  • Tax planning flexibility – The ability to time dividends, make pension contributions, and take advantage of allowances offers more control over personal tax.

  • Expense claims – Business expenses such as equipment, software, professional subscriptions, and travel (where eligible) can be claimed.

  • Professional credibility – Many end clients and agencies prefer engaging with limited companies, especially for longer contracts.

  • Limited liability – As a director, your personal assets are protected, as liability is limited to the company.

Considerations:

  • You’ll need to manage company accounts, tax filings, and statutory obligations, usually with the help of an accountant.

  • Corporation Tax, VAT, and personal tax responsibilities must be met on time.

  • IR35 legislation can restrict tax efficiency, meaning not all contracts are suitable for limited company working.

  • Setting up and closing a company carries costs and responsibilities.

Umbrella Company: Stress-Free and Straightforward

For contractors who want to keep things simple, an umbrella company provides an easy way to get paid without the need to run a business. The umbrella acts as your employer, taking care of PAYE tax, National Insurance, and compliance.

Best suited for contractors who:

  • Want minimal administration and prefer everything to be managed for them

  • Take on short-term, ad hoc, or one-off contracts

  • Are working on contracts inside IR35, where a limited company provides no tax advantage

  • Earn under £25,000 a year or are contracting between permanent roles

Key benefits:

  • Fully managed payroll – The umbrella processes your pay via PAYE, with tax and National Insurance deducted before payment.

  • Employment rights – You’re legally classed as an employee of the umbrella company, so you’re entitled to statutory sick pay, holiday pay, and a workplace pension.

  • Quick setup – Registration is straightforward, often allowing you to start working the same day.

  • Low admin – All compliance, payroll, and tax obligations are handled for you.

Considerations:

  • Lower take-home pay – You’ll usually take home less than with a limited company, as PAYE is less tax-efficient than dividends.

  • Expense restrictions – Since the introduction of the Supervision, Direction, or Control (SDC) rules, most travel and subsistence expenses cannot be claimed.

  • Umbrella fees – A weekly or monthly margin is deducted from your pay, typically between £15–£25.

Making the Right Choice

There is no one-size-fits-all answer. The best option depends on your contract length, IR35 status, earnings, and appetite for administration.

  • A limited company usually suits professional contractors seeking maximum take-home pay and who are comfortable with some responsibility over finances.

  • An umbrella company is often better for short-term or lower-paid contracts, or where compliance is more important than tax efficiency.

If you’re weighing up your options, you can compare providers directly on our site:

Scroll to Top
Scroll to Top